A.I. Vlasov − Ph.D. (Eng.), Associate Professor, Deputy of Head of Department,

Department «Designing and Technology of Electronic Devices», 

Bauman Moscow State Technical University (Moscow, Russia)

E-mail: vlasovai@bmstu.ru

E.A. Marikova − Magister,

Department «Designing and Technology of Electronic Devices «,  Bauman Moscow State Technical University (Moscow, Russia)

E-mail: marikova_e@mail.ru  

Statement of a problem. Modern technical and organizational control structures should be considered from the point of view of the analysis of complex systems. Analysis of the principles of building such systems is possible by formalizing their architecture using visual modeling technologies, such as ARIS and ArchiMate. The selection of specific technology solutions should be guided by wellreasoned criteria to assess the completeness of the supported standards. The paper presents the methodology of multi-criteria ranking of visual tools according to 8 types of characteristics, which allows you to analyze promising ones and choose the best tool depending on specific goals and tasks.

Purpose. Conduct a comparative analysis of ARIS and ArchiMate notations as well as visual tools for the development of production system models and provide sound recommendations on the choice of a particular solution for specific tasks in practice.

Results. This article summarizes and systematizes the technologies of visual modeling of production systems. Based on the results of a comprehensive comparison of technologies of visual modeling of the organization's architecture using ARIS methods and ArchiMate yes recommendations for their application. The main objective of this article is to study and compare existing promising notations and tools in the field of visual modeling that implement ARIS and ArchiMate methods.

Practical importance. The paper provides recommendations on the use of visual modeling technologies, which allows you to create a detailed architecture of active complex systems, which allows you to provide a common understanding of basic organizational and logistical solutions, strategic goals and tactical requirements when managing complex systems. Classification of visual modeling technologies has been carried out. The proposed solutions can be used to formalize production processes in the context of the digital transformation of industry and the social sector. Based on a comparative analysis of tools, a method of criterion ranking has been proposed, which allows for a reasoned choice taking into account the support of ARIS and ArchiMate notations, castomization, the possibility of implementing joint activities, and the generation of reporting documentation.

1. Peregudov F.I., Tarasenko F.P. Vvedenie v sistemnyj analiz: Ucheb. posobie dlya VUZov. M.: Vysshaya shkola. 1989 (In Russian).
2. Pospelov D.A. Bol'shie sistemy. Situacionnoe upravlenie. M.: Znanie. 1975. 64 s. (In Russian).
3. Pospelov D.A. Situacionnoe upravlenie: teoriya i praktika. M.: Nauka. 1986. 288 s. (In Russian).
4. Lomako E.I. Matematicheskie i ponyatijnye sredstva sistemantiki. M.: Sistemnaya enciklopediya. 2008. 112 s. (In Russian).
5. Povarov G.N. Ob urovnyah slozhnosti sistem. Materialy Vsesoyuznoj konferencii «Metodologicheskie problemy kibernetiki». M. 1970.  T. 2. (In Russian).
6. Denisov A.A., Kolesnikov D.M. Teoriya bol'shih sistem upravleniya. L.: Energoizdat. 1982. (In Russian).
7. Burkov V.N., Novikov D.A. Teoriya aktivnyh sistem: sostoyanie i perspektivy. M.: Sinteg. 1999. (In Russian).
8. Burkov V.N., Novikov D.A. Teoriya aktivnyh sistem (Istoriya razvitiya i sovremennoe sostoyanie). Problemy upravleniya. 2009. № 3.1. S. 28−35 (In Russian).
9. Shakhnov V.A., Kurnosenko A.Ye. Modelirovaniye tsifrovogo proizvodstva elektronnoy apparatury v ramkakh kontseptsii «Industriya 4.0». V sbornike: Tsifrovaya transformatsiya promyshlennosti: tendentsii, upravleniye, strategii Materi-aly I Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoprakticheskoy konferentsii. Otvetstvennyy redaktor V.V. Akberdina. 2019. S. 585-594 (In Russian).
10. Karpunin A.A., Vlasov A.I. Obrabotka dannykh s raspredelennym reyestrom v kontseptsii «Industriya 4.0». V sbornike: Energosberezheniye i effektivnost' v tekhnicheskikh sistemakh Materialy V Mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-tekhnicheskoy konferentsii studentov, molodykh uchonykh i spetsialistov. 2018. S. 120-121. (In Russian).
11. Vlasov A.I., Ganev YU.M., Karpunin A.A. Kartirovaniye potoka sozdaniya tsennostey v kontseptsii «Berezhlivogo proizvodstva». Informatsionnyye tekhnologii v proyektirovanii i proizvodstve. 2016. № 2 (162). S. 23-27 (In Russian). 
12. Karpunin A.A., Kozlov A.A. Analiz metodov realizatsii detsentralizovannykh prilozheniy v konstruktorsko-tekhnologicheskoy informatike. Informatsionnyye tekhnologii v proyektirovanii i proizvodstve. 2017. № 4 (168). S. 39-44 (In Russian).
13. Vlasov A.I., Ganev YU.M., Karpunin A.A. Sistema 5s-tekhnologiya sozdaniya effektivnogo rabochego mesta v kontseptsii «Berezhlivogo proizvodstva». Informatsionnyye tekhnologii v proyektirovanii i proizvodstve. 2016. № 1 (161). S. 65-68 (In Russian).
14. Arkhitektura programmnogo obespecheniya: ArchiMate. [Elektronnyy resurs] — Rezhim dostupa: http://sewiki.ru/ArchiMate#.D0.A3.D1.80.D0.BE.D0.B2.D0.BD.D0.B8_ArchiMate, svobodnyy. — Data obrashcheniya: 05.03.2020. 
15. Arkhitektura programmnogo obespecheniya. Vikipediya. Svobodnaya entsiklopediya [Elektronnyy resurs] — Rezhim dostupa: ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arkhitektura_programmnogo_obespecheniya, svobodnyy. — Data obrashcheniya: 05.03.2020
16. Koptelov A.K. Modelirovaniye arkhitektury na baze spetsifikatsii ArchiMate 3.0. [Elektronnyy resurs] — Rezhim dostupa: https://www.businessstudio.ru/upload/iblock/65c/Koptelov.pdf., svobodnyy. — Data obrashcheniya: 05.03.2020
17. Levenchuk A.I. ArchiMate po-russki: metod opisaniya informatsionnoy struktury. [Elektronnyy resurs] — Rezhim dostupa: https://ailev.livejournal.com/955954.html., svobodnyy. — Data obrashcheniya: 05.03.2020
18. Iacob M-E., Jonkers H. ArchiMate 2.1 Specification: Technical Standart. [Elektronnyy resurs] — Rezhim dostupa: https://pubs.opengroup.org/architecture/archimate2-doc/m/chap05.html., svobod-nyy. — Data obrashcheniya: 05.03.2020 
19. Kocheshkov A.E., Karpunin A.A. Tekhnologiya archimate - novyy standart modelirovaniya arkhitektury predpriyatiya. In-formatsionnyye tekhnologii v proyektirovanii i proizvodstve. 2017. № 4 (168). S. 3-9 (In Russian).
20. Vlasov A.I. Sistemnyy analiz tekhnologicheskikh protsessov proizvodstva slozhnykh tekhnicheskikh sistem s ispol'zova-niyem vizual'nykh modeley. Mezhdunarodnyy nauchno-issledovatel'skiy zhurnal. 2013. № 10-2(17). S. 17−26 (In Russian).
21. Vlasov A.I. Kontseptsiya vizual'nogo analiza slozhnykh sistem v usloviyakh sinkhronnykh tekhnologiy proyektirovaniya. Datchiki i sistemy. 2016. № 8−9(206). S. 19−25 (In Russian). 
22. Demin A.A., Kondratyuk A.V. Analiz metodik proyektirovaniya modeley proizvodstvennykh sistem. Informatsionnyye tekhnologii v proyektirovanii i proizvodstve. 2018. № 1 (169). S. 3-9 (In Russian). 
23. Vlasov A.I. Prostranstvennaya model' otsenki evolyutsii metodov vizual'nogo proyektirovaniya slozhnykh sistem. Datchiki i sistemy. 2013. № 9 (172). S. 10−28 (In Russian).
24. Vlasov A.I., Zhuravleva L.V., Kazakov V.V. Primeneniye vizual'nykh instrumentov BPMN dlya modelirovaniya tekhnologicheskoy podgotovki proizvodstva. Informatsionnyye tekhnologii v proyektirovanii i proizvodstve. 2019. № 4 (In Russian). 
25. Vlasov A.I., Gonoshilov D.S. Sistemnyy analiz proizvodstva s ispol'zovaniyem vizual'nykh instrumentov BPMN. Informatsionnyye tekhnologii v proyektirovanii i proizvodstve. 2019. № 3(175). S. 10−16 (In Russian). 
26. Vlasov A.I., Zhuravleva L.V., Kazakov V.V. Analiz sredstv razrabotki vizual'nykh bpmn-modeley slozhnykh sistem. Dinamika slozhnykh sistem - XXI vek. 2020. T. 14. № 1. S. 5-22 (In Russian).
27. ARIS Express − Free Modeling Software | ARIS BPM Community URL: https://www.ariscommunity.com/aris-express (data obrashcheniya: 25.12.2019).
28. Vlasov A.I. Sistemnyy analiz proizvodstva c ispol'zovaniyem vizual'nykh instrumentov metodologii ARIS. Trudy mezhdunarodnogo simpoziuma Nadezhnost' i kachestvo. 2018. T. 1. S. 21−32 (In Russian).
29. Chernen'kiy V.M., Gapanyuk YU.Ye., Revunkov G.I., Terekhov V.I., Kaganov YU.T. Metagrafovyy podkhod dlya opisaniya gi-bridnykh intellektual'nykh informatsionnykh sistem. Prikladnaya informatika. 2017. T. 12. № 3 (69). S. 57-79 (In Russian).
30. Chernen'kiy V.M. Algoritmicheskiy metod opisaniya diskretnykh protsessov funktsionirovaniya sistem. Informatsionno-izmeritel'nyye i upravlyayushchiye sistemy. 2016. T. 14. № 12. S. 11-21 (In Russian). 
31. Vanroyye N.K., Karpunin A.A. Analiz printsipov biznes-planirovaniya IT-proyekta. Informatsionnyye tekhnologii v proyektirovanii i proizvodstve. 2018. № 4(172). S. 31-35 (In Russian).