D.G. Pantenkov

JSC «Kronstadt» (Moscow, Russia) 

Currently, the use of aviation systems with unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) of various classes and purpose for the benefit of both special customers and civilian purposes has acquired particular relevance and practical significance. Modern UAVs, used both separately and as part of the group, can carry several target loads on board at the same time, built on various physical principles: multifunctional optoelectronic system, digital aerial photography system, on-board radar station, radio and radio reconnaissance system, communication system for transmitting data from target loads (sensors) to a mobile device (for example, a tablet) to a remote subscriber, etc. At the same time, the issue of determining the evaluation of the effectiveness of solving both individual target tasks of UAVs and finding an integral assessment of the effectiveness of using aircraft systems with UAVs when solving a set of target tasks (sequentially or sequentially-in parallel in time), taking into account their priority and a number of other factors, remains practically unlit. The scientific and technical article consists structurally of three parts and is devoted to the consideration of the issues of finding an integral assessment of the effectiveness of the use of aviation systems with unmanned aerial vehicles. In the first part of article [1], a scientific and methodological approach has been developed to determine estimates of the effectiveness of solving private target problems of radio communication and remote monitoring (by optical and radar means) by a complex with UAVs. The second part of the article presents a mathematical apparatus for assessing the effectiveness of solving problems of conducting radio-technical reconnaissance and aircraft destruction of targets. As a criterion for the effectiveness of solving all private target problems, a universal indicator of the probability of solving them has been adopted, which will ultimately allow for convolution and determine an integral assessment of the effectiveness of solving a whole set of target problems. The methodological apparatus developed in the article is universal and invariant to the input parameters, that is, the number of solved target problems, the stage of operation of the complex with UAVs, and can be easily adapted to the new conditions for the use of other complexes with UAVs. Within the framework of this approach, a mathematical apparatus for functional dependence of probabilities of solving particular target problems with design parameters of target loads in the UAV has been developed, taking into account the peculiarities of its functioning and in the conditions of existing restrictions and assumptions. The scientific and methodological approach allows already at the stage of formation of the tactical and technical task for the complex with UAVs to obtain quantitative estimates of the probabilities of solving private target tasks using the technical backlog of industrial enterprises for key components from the complex (target loads, a set of communication facilities, etc.). Finding effectiveness estimates in the group application of UAVs, as well as taking into account possible electronic counteraction, goes beyond the scope of this article and is the direction of further research on this topic.

Pantenkov D.G. Methodological approach to integrated effectiveness assessment apply of aviation systems with UAVs. Evaluating methods for effectiveness of solving radio technical reconnaissance and aircraft destruction of targets tasks. Achievements of modern radioelectronics. 2021. V. 75. № 3. P. 32–52. DOI: https://doi.org/10.18127/j20700784-202103-02 [in Russian]

1. Pantenkov D.G. Metodicheskiy podkhod k integral'noy otsenke effektivnosti primeneniya aviatsionnykh kompleksov s BPLA. Chast' 1. Metodiki otsenki effektivnosti resheniya zadach radiosvyazi i distantsionnogo monitoringa. Trudy uchebnykh zavedeniy svyazi. 2020. T. 6. № 2. S. 60–78. [in Russian]
2. Pantenkov D.G., Gusakov N.V., Sokolov V.M. Metodika integral'noy otsenki effektivnosti resheniya kompleksa tselevykh zadach kosmicheskim apparatom mnogotselevoy kosmicheskoy sistemy. Aktual'nye voprosy proektirovaniya kosmicheskikh sistem i kompleksov. Sb. nauch. trudov aspirantov i soiskateley uchenykh stepeney. Khimki: AO «NPO Lavochkina». 2013. V. 14. S. 65–86. [in Russian]
3. Pantenkov D.G., Gusakov N.V., Sokolov V.M., Velikoivanenko V.I., Konstantinov V.S. Kompleks metodik otsenki effektivnosti resheniya chastnykh tselevykh zadach voennogo vremeni kosmicheskim apparatom mnogotselevoy kosmicheskoy sistemy. Aktual'nye voprosy proektirovaniya kosmicheskikh sistem i kompleksov. Sb. nauch. trudov aspirantov i soiskateley uchenykh stepeney. Khimki: AO «NPO Lavochkina». 2014. V. 15. S. 107–150. [in Russian]
4. Pantenkov D.G., Gusakov N.V., Sokolov V.M., Velikoivanenko V.I., Lomakin A.A. Kompleks metodik otsenki effektivnosti resheniya chastnykh tselevykh zadach mirnogo vremeni kosmicheskim apparatom mnogotselevoy kosmicheskoy sistemy. Aktual'nye voprosy proektirovaniya kosmicheskikh sistem i kompleksov. Sb. nauch. trudov aspirantov i soiskateley uchenykh stepeney. Khimki: AO «NPO Lavochkina». 2014. V. 15. S. 89–106. [in Russian]
5. Mel'nikov Yu.P., Popov S.V. Radiotekhnicheskaya razvedka. Metody otsenki effektivnosti mestoopredeleniya istochnikov izlucheniya. M.: Radiotekhnika. 2008. [in Russian]
6. Radzievskiy V.G., Sirota A.A. Teoreticheskie osnovy radioelektronnoy razvedki. Izd. 2-e, ispr. i dop. M.: Radiotekhnika. 2004. [in Russian]
7. Venttsel' E.S. Vvedenie v issledovanie operatsiy. M.: Sov. radio. 1964. [in Russian]
8. Verba V.S., Tatarskiy B.G. Kompleksy s bespilotnymi letatel'nymi apparatami. V 2-kh knigakh. M.: Radiotekhnika. 2016. [in Russian]
9. Sklyar B. Tsifrovaya svyaz'. Teoreticheskie osnovy i prakticheskoe primenenie: Per. s angl. M.: Vil'yams. 2003. [in Russian]
10. Merkulov V.I., Drogalin V.V., Kanashchenkov A.I. i dr. Aviatsionnye sistemy radioupravleniya. T. 1. Printsipy postroeniya sistem radioupravleniya. Osnovy sinteza i analiza. M.: Radiotekhnika. 2003. [in Russian]
11. Rostopchin V.V. Elementarnye osnovy otsenki effektivnosti primeneniya bespilotnykh aviatsionnykh sistem dlya vozdushnoy razvedki. URL: http://www.uav.ru/articles/basic_uav_efficiency.pdf. [in Russian]
12. Patent na poleznuyu model' RUS 191165. Bortovoy terminal radiosvyazi bespilotnogo letatel'nogo apparata. Dolzhenkov N.N., Abramov A.V., Egorov A.T., Lomakin A.A., Pantenkov D.G. Byul. № 21. Prior. ot 26.07.2019. [in Russian]
13. Egorov A.T., Lomakin A.A., Pantenkov D.G. Matematicheskie modeli otsenki skrytnosti sputnikovykh kanalov radiosvyazi s bespilotnymi letatel'nymi apparatami. Ch. 1. Trudy uchebnykh zavedeniy svyazi. 2019. T. 5. № 3. S. 19–26. DOI:10.31854/1813-324X-2019-5-3-19-26.  [in Russian]
14. Lomakin A.A., Pantenkov D.G., Sokolov V.M. Matematicheskie modeli otsenki skrytnosti sputnikovykh kanalov radiosvyazi s bespilotnymi  letatel'nymi apparatami. Ch. 2. Trudy uchebnykh zavedeniy svyazi. 2019. T. 5. № 4. S. 37–48. DOI:10.31854/1813-324X-2019-5-4-37-48.  [in Russian]
15. Pantenkov D.G., Gusakov N.V., Egorov A.T., Lomakin A.A., Litvinenko V.P., Velikoivanenko V.I. i dr. Tekhnicheskaya realizatsiya  vysokoskorostnogo informatsionnogo kanala radiosvyazi s bespilotnogo letatel'nogo apparata na nazemnyy punkt upravleniya. Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta. 2019. T. 15. № 5. S. 52–71. [in Russian]
16. Pantenkov D.G., Lomakin A.A. Otsenka ustoychivosti sputnikovogo kanala upravleniya bespilotnymi letatel'nymi apparatami pri vozdeystvii prednamerennykh pomekh. Radiotekhnika. 2019. T. 83. № 11(17). S. 43–50. DOI:10.18127/j00338486-201911(17)-04. [in Russian]
17. Dolzhenkov N.N., Pantenkov D.G., Egorov A.T., Lomakin A.A., Litvinenko V.P., Velikoivanenko V.I., Lyu-Ke-Syu E.Yu. Tekhnicheskie kharakteristiki kompleksa sredstv sputnikovoy radiosvyazi s bespilotnymi letatel'nymi apparatami. Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta. 2019. T. 15. № 3. S. 74–82. [in Russian]
18. Dolzhenkov N.N., Pantenkov D.G., Litvinenko V.P., Lomakin A.A., Egorov A.T., Gritsenko A.A. Integrirovannyy kompleks dal'ney radiosvyazi dlya povysheniya effektivnosti resheniya tselevykh zadach bespilotnymi letatel'nymi apparatami. Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta. 2019. T. 15. № 3. S. 102–108. DOI:10.25987/VSTU.2019.15.3.015. [in Russian]
19. Pantenkov D.G. Rezul'taty analiza nazemnykh ispytaniy kompleksa sredstv sputnikovoy radiosvyazi dlya bespilotnykh letatel'nykh apparatov. Vestnik Ryazanskogo gosudarstvennogo radiotekhnicheskogo universiteta, 2019. № 69. S. 42–51. [in Russian]
20. Mel'nikov Yu.P. Vozdushnaya radiotekhnicheskaya razvedka (metody otsenki effektivnosti). M.: Radiotekhnika. 2005. [in Russian]
21. Moiseev V.S., Tutubalin P.I. K probleme obespecheniya informatsionnoy bezopasnosti bespilotnykh aviatsionnykh kompleksov. VI Mezhdunar. nauch.-tekhnich. konf. «Problemy i perspektivy razvitiya aviatsii, nazemnogo transporta i energetiki» (ANTE-2011, Kazan', Rossiya, 12–14 oktyabrya 2011). T. 2. Kazan': Kazanskiy gosudarstvennyy tekhnicheskiy universitet im. A.N. Tupoleva. 2011. S. 324–331.  [in Russian]
22. Moiseev V.S. Osnovnye napravleniya resheniya problem teorii i praktiki rossiyskoy bespilotnoy aviatsionnoy tekhniki. Mezhdunar. nauch.-praktich. konf. «Sovremennye tekhnologii, materialy, oborudovanie i uskorennoe vosstanovlenie kvalifitsirovannogo kadrovogo potentsiala – klyuchevye zven'ya v vozrozhdenii otechestvennogo avia- i raketostroeniya» (Kazan', Rossiya, 14–16 avgusta 2012).  Kazan': Vertolet. 2012. T. 2. S. 152–163. [in Russian]
23. Moiseev V.S. Rossiyskaya bespilotnaya aviatsionnaya tekhnika: osnovnye problemy i puti resheniya. X Vseross. nauch.-tekhnich. konf. «Nauchnye chteniya po aviatsii, posvyashchennye pamyati N.E. Zhukovskogo». M.: Izd. dom Akademii im. N.E. Zhukovskogo. 2013. T. 1. S. 470–474. [in Russian]
24. Moiseev V.S., Gushchina D.S., Moiseev G.V. Osnovy teorii sozdaniya i primeneniya informatsionnykh bespilotnykh aviatsionnykh kompleksov. Ser. «Sovremennaya prikladnaya matematika i informatika». Kazan': MOiN RT. 2010. [in Russian]
25. Moiseev G.V., Moiseev V.S. Osnovy teorii sozdaniya i primeneniya imitatsionnykh bespilotnykh aviatsionnykh kompleksov. Ser. «Sovremennaya prikladnaya matematika i informatika». Kazan': Redaktsionno-izdatel'skiy tsentr. 2013. [in Russian]
26. Makarov I.M., Lokhin V.M., Man'ko S.V. i dr. Intellektual'nye sistemy upravleniya bespilotnymi letatel'nymi apparatami na osnove kompleksnogo primeneniya tekhnologiy nechetkoy logiki i assotsiativnoy pamyati. Aviakosmicheskoe priborostroenie. 2002. № 2. S. 29–36. [in Russian]
27. Zheltov S.Yu., Vizil'ter Yu.V. Perspektivy intellektualizatsii sistem upravleniya LA za schet primeneniya mashinnogo zreniya. Trudy Moskovskogo fiziko-tekhnicheskogo instituta. 2009. T. 1. № 4. S. 164–181. [in Russian]
28. Pavlov A.M. Printsipy organizatsii bortovykh vychislitel'nykh sistem perspektivnykh letatel'nykh apparatov. Mir komp'yuternoy avtomatizatsii. 2001. № 4. [in Russian]
29. Pantenkov D.G. Rezul'taty matematicheskogo modelirovaniya pomekhoustoychivosti sputnikovykh radionavigatsionnykh sistem pri vozdeystvii prednamerennykh pomekh. Uspekhi sovremennoy radioelektroniki. 2020. T. 74. № 2. S. 57–68. DOI: 10.18127/j20700784202002-05. [in Russian]
30. Vikulov O.V., Dobykin V.D., Drogalin V.V. i dr. Sovremennoe sostoyanie i perspektivy razvitiya aviatsionnykh sredstv radioelektronnoy bor'by. Zarubezhnaya radioelektronika. Uspekhi sovremennoy radioelektroniki. 1998. № 12. S. 3–16. [in Russian]
31. Osipov G.S., Tikhomirov I.A., Khachumov V.M., Yakovlev K.S. Intellektual'nye sistemy upravleniya avtonomnymi transportnymi sredstvami: standarty, proekty, realizatsiya. Aviakosmicheskoe priborostroenie. 2009. № 6. S. 34–43. [in Russian]
32. Sentyabrev O.I., Malyshev V.A. Primenenie elementov iskusstvennogo intellekta dlya resheniya zadach zashchity samoleta ot upravlyaemykh raket v vozdushnom boyu. XII Mezhdunar. nauch.-tekhnich. konf. «Kibernetika i vysokie tekhnologii XXI veka» (C&T-2011, Voronezh, Rossiya, 11–13 maya 2011). Voronezh: Voronezhskiy gosudarstvennyy universitet. 2011. T. 2. S. 497–503. [in Russian]
33. Pantenkov D.G., Litvinenko V.P. Algoritmy formirovaniya i obrabotki radiosignalov komandno-telemetricheskoy radiolinii i tekhnicheskie predlozheniya po ikh realizatsii. Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta. 2020. T. 16. № 2. S. 90–105. DOI:10.25987/VSTU.2020.16.2.014. [in Russian]
34. Pantenkov D.G., Litvinenko V.P. Tsifrovaya statisticheskaya imitatsionnaya model' protsessa obrabotki signalov v navigatsionnoy apparature potrebiteley sputnikovykh radionavigatsionnykh sistem. Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta. 2020. T. 16. № 1. S. 87–99. DOI:10.25987/VSTU.2020.16.1.011. [in Russian]
35. Pantenkov D.G., Litvinenko V.P. Tekhnicheskaya realizatsiya kriticheskikh uzlov i ustroystv priema shirokopolosnykh radiosignalov. Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta, 2020. T. 16. № 3. S. 34–45. [in Russian]
36. Khalil M. Intellektual'nye tekhnologii prinyatiya resheniy po upravleniyu tekhnicheskimi sredstvami v sistemakh obrabotki informatsii. Vestnik Voronezhskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnicheskogo universiteta. 2009. T. 5. № 7. S. 10–13. [in Russian]